RSS Feed Icon

Site News

The 5 Most Underrated Players in the 2008 NFL Draft

Tuesday, February 26, 2008 by Michael Keller

This report was submitted to us by Michael Keller.  Michael is the author of the highest rated, most viewed mock draft on MyMockDraft at the moment.  Here is a list of his top 5 most underrated players in this year's draft.

5. Josh Johnson - QB - San Diego

He has been shooting up draft boards since the Senior Bowl and now his Combine workouts, but I still feel he will go lower than he should. Josh played under Jim Harbaugh, who was a quarterback in the NFL as recently as 2001, which is only going to help his adjustment. He is a mobile QB (ran a 4.40 40 yd dash at the combine), but without question looks to pass the ball before tucking it and running if nothing is there. He proved during senior bowl practices and during the game that he can make any throw on the football field. Has solid height at 6-2, and generally makes good decisions. The only possible knock is the level of competition he played against, but many players have overcome that before, and I believe Johnson is going to be a franchise quarterback within the next 2 or 3 years for whoever is smart enough to draft him.

Current Player Comparison: Donovan McNabb

4. Phillip Wheeler - MLB - Georgia Tech

Played under Jon Tenuta, who is one of the best defensive coordinators in the country. He is a very intelligent middle linebacker who can be a very good player and a mainstay on defense for the next decade. Adequate speed, and plays faster with pads on than most people. A sure tackler in the open field and can deliver the big hit. Tends to make plays behind the line of scrimmage, but that can tie into his weakness, which is that he over runs holes sometimes. There are NFL coaches who can help him work on that. Will probably be drafted in the 2nd or 3rd round, which I think can be a steal for him. If he can learn to quickly read plays in the NFL, he could be one of the best Middle Linebackers in the league.

Current Player Comparison: Nick Barnett

3. Ali Highsmith - OLB - LSU

An outstanding player on an outstanding defense, I haven't heard Highsmith's named mentioned as a first round possibility, which bewilders me. Extremely fast and is pretty good at reading plays. Doesn't have outstanding lower body strength, but can work on that in the NFL. Is much better in the open field making plays, and, once engaged,  can get sucked up by bigger blockers. But that comes back to his lower body strength, which will be worked on from day one in the NFL. Kind of splitting hairs, as he is pretty good at avoiding those same blockers who have the ability to cancel him out. If he can develop lower body strength and learn a little better technique when taking on blockers, can be a stud in the NFL.

Current Player Comparison: Lance Briggs

2. Corey Lynch - S - Appalachian State

I'll preface this one by saying that I did go Appalachian State for a year and am a huge fan of their football team. But Lynch started at safety, and was the best player on defense all 3 years that App State won the 1-AA National Championship. Has a very good sense of the moment, as he typically found a way to make a game changing play in most any game he played in (Example: blocked the game winning field goal against Michigan). He also in that same Michigan game made a few very good defensive plays against Big Ten athletes at Wide Receiver. During the 1-AA tournaments each of those three years, would come up with big play after big play that helped them win all 3 National Championships. Not the fastest or tallest player, but is always in outstanding position and, as previously stated, would come up with every big play that needed to be made. Not necessarily a first round draft pick, just given speed and height, but I think is definitely a sleeper for being drafted after round 4, which is what I'm hearing about him right now.

Current Player Comparison: Darren Sharper

1. Brandon Flowers - CB - Virginia Tech

Another player who had a big time sense of the moment. He made a lot of plays in every game for Virginia Tech. Won multiple games with an interception or a big pass deflection. When he does get his hands on the ball, almost always intercepts it and returns it a long way to set up his teams offense. Above average speed and has very good closing speed, hardly ever getting beat on the deep ball. Not great in press coverage, given his size, but can handle his own in man coverage. Another very good corner in the long line of great ones coming out of Virginia Tech. Strikingly similar to Dre Bly when he came out of Carolina almost a decade ago, with some of the same questions about height and speed. I feel just like Bly did in college, Flowers has proved he is able to make big plays.

Current Player Comparison: Dre Bly

*Current Player Comparison is not who I think these players are equal too right now. It's more of if they reach their potential, players that I feel they can make a similar impact as if they reach their potential.

If you are interested in contributing on MyMockDraft, please contact us.  We are looking for a few writers to cover various NFL teams and NCAA conferences.

Comments (11)

  1. Hey man excellent article..I like the fact you gave due to some of the small school players I mentioned in mine. I think you should have included Dexter Jackson with his speed and hands he should be getting more attention in my opinion.

    Posted by Ozzfan1317 | 2/26/2008
  2. Completely agree honestly. But since I went to Appalachian State for a year, as I mentioned in Corey Lynch's explanation, I didn't want to seem like I was coming off as a homer. Dexter is starting to get his due since he ran a 4.28 at the combine. Lynch wasn't even invited to combine, which is ridiculous. App State had another player who could be very good too, Kerry Brown - started all three years at O-Line that they won the title. That's honestly the only reason.

    Posted by mikek4687 | 2/26/2008
  3. Highsmith had a bad combine, also Chris Johnson rb from, ecu, I believe can be very underated as well as Matt Forte rb from Tulane. Although I do agree with all that you said, Look for Wesley Woodyard lb from Kentucky to suprise people as well he really impressed some eyes at the combine. I also love Anthony Aldridge rb from houston I just saw some tape of him not to long ago and he reminds me a lot of Drew Jones from the Jags, Great steel if drafted or not in the later rounds.

    Posted by patriots78 | 2/27/2008
  4. Yeh, Highsmith had a terrible combine. He ran a 5.0 40 yd dash, which is obviously awful. I did this before he performed at the combine, but also he plays faster in pads. I think he's a little out of shape and will move back up a little after LSU's pro day. The 40 yd dash is great and all, but not many times a football game will you sprint 40 yds in a t-shirt and shorts. He's proven at LSU that he's a very good player, and I still believe he will be a solid pro player.

    Posted by mikek4687 | 2/27/2008
  5. Johnson also had a terrible combine. If anything hes losing stock. One scout said his 1st pass was a duck and some how they got consistantly worse. He was waiting for people to start shooting them out of the air. He said he would have to talk to Harbaugh to see what the problem was. He better have a good Pro Day if he want to get drafted.

    Posted by F Mel Kiper Jr. | 2/28/2008
  6. Not according to the people at espn. They said he threw well and ran well, so I don't think that's too bad. I don't know where you got that from, but I haven't heard it. They actually pointed him out as making a good impression.

    Posted by mikek4687 | 2/28/2008
  7. Johson was raived about by Mayock he even said that he was suprised that more people aren't talking about more.

    Posted by patriots78 | 2/29/2008
  8. yeh I watch espn a lot and mcshay said that he impressed a lot of scouts with his throwing. not to mention he ran a 4.40 in the 40.

    Posted by mikek4687 | 2/29/2008
  9. good stuff but i think the brandon flowers-dre bly comparison is way off. they have similar size and ball skills but flowers is 10 times more physical. bly always shies from contact. bly has more speed aswell

    Posted by bigkat21 | 3/1/2008
  10. their comparison had a lot to do with college side as well. being very productive college players who will probably both fall the 2nd round. I believe St. Louis drafted Dre Bly in the 2nd round (pick 41) in 1999. flowers ran slower at the combine, but I think he plays faster than he runs (more game speed). Bly isn't overly fast either though, he ran a 4.51 at the combine. i think flowers ran a 4.58 but im not positive, either way there isn't a big speed difference. I agree for the most part with flowers being more physical, but it's hard to pin point one player who is exactly the same. i thought bly was close.

    Posted by mikek4687 | 3/1/2008
  11. Don't forget the official results came in and Johnson's time was faster than McFaddens he's in a lot of peoples top five rb and may have sneeked into the first round mid to late.

    Posted by patriots78 | 3/3/2008